Free to compare · No sign-up
How it worksAd disclosure
Article

Pawn Shops Got Back About 4 in 10 Loan Dollars by Selling the Collateral. Don't Pawn Gold You Won't Redeem.

High gold prices are making pawn loans bigger. EZCORP's new annual report says its U.S. pawn loans earned 13% a month, and its cash flow shows about 41% of the loan principal it got back came from selling forfeited items, not repayments. FirstCash's number is about 38%. If you're not sure you can pay it off, selling beats pawning.

Gold cuff bracelet, twisted gold ring and a pendant necklace resting in a wooden tray

Gold is up, so that chain in your jewelry box borrows more at the pawn counter than it did a year ago. Before you hand it over for holiday cash, look at what happens to the loans these chains make.

EZCORP, the second-largest pawn chain in the U.S. by store count, filed its annual report on November 12. Its pawn loans outstanding ended the fiscal year at $269.4 million, up 15%, “driven by higher average loan size, as rising gold prices resulted in higher jewelry collateral.” Jewelry now makes up 72% of the collateral in its U.S. stores.

What the loan costs

EZCORP says U.S. pawn charges “generally vary between 12% and 25% per month,” and its typical loan is $230 to $250. The company’s monthly average yield on U.S. pawn loans was 13%.

Run that on a $240 loan:

  • 13% a month: about $31 a month, or $94 over a 90-day term.
  • 25% a month, the top of the range: $60 a month, or $180 over 90 days.

Multiply by 12 and that’s roughly 156% to 300% a year, which is why it gets quoted by the month.

How often the item isn’t coming back

Neither chain publishes a forfeiture rate, so we computed a proxy from their own cash flow statements. When a loan ends, the principal comes back one of two ways: you repay it, or the shop sells your item.

ChainPeriodRepaidRecovered by selling forfeited itemsShare from forfeits
EZCORPFY ended Sept. 30, 2026$723.2M$496.7M40.7%
FirstCashJan. to Sept. 2026$1,143.1M$711.9M38.4%

About 4 in 10 loan dollars ended with the item sold. This is weighted by dollars, not loans, and it includes both chains’ Latin American stores. It’s still the clearest number either company gives you.

EZCORP is plain about the downside to you: when collateral is forfeited, the company does “not record losses or charge-offs.” The shop is covered either way.

The shop knows what your gold is worth

EZCORP’s U.S. jewelry scrap sales doubled, up 100% to $171.2 million, at a 31.6% gross margin. In plain terms, the gold it scrapped sold for about $1.46 for every $1 it paid or lent against it.

The move

If you’re sure you can repay in the first term, a pawn loan is a short, expensive bridge that keeps your ring. If you’re not sure, it’s a slow way to sell the ring at the shop’s price after paying fees first. That’s a bad trade.

So:

  1. Only pawn what you’ll redeem on schedule. Borrow the smallest amount you need, since fees scale with the loan.
  2. If you might not redeem, sell instead. Get quotes from two other buyers before taking the first number.
  3. Price the alternatives. A federal credit union payday alternative loan is capped at 28% a year. Compare it in our loan calculator and on our loans hub.
  4. Check your state’s rate. Texas, for one, has rate tiers with a cliff.
  5. Military? The Military Lending Act caps pawn loans to covered service members and dependents at a 36% military APR, per EZCORP’s own filing.

How Candid Yak makes money. Some of the products we write about pay us if you apply or sign up through our links. That never changes our verdict, our rankings, or the numbers in this article. We call a bad deal a bad deal whether it pays us or not. Some brands shown in our comparison tools are placeholder examples while we finalize partner agreements, and we label them as such.

Frequently asked questions

How much does a pawn loan cost?

EZCORP, the second-largest U.S. pawn chain by store count, says in its fiscal 2026 annual report that U.S. pawn service charges generally run 12% to 25% a month, depending on state law, on terms of 30 to 90 days. Its average U.S. pawn loan is $230 to $250, and its monthly average yield on U.S. pawn loans was 13%. On a $240 loan, 13% a month is about $31 a month, or about $94 over a 90-day term. That works out to roughly 156% a year.

What share of pawned items are never picked up?

Neither chain publishes a forfeiture rate. Candid Yak calculated one proxy from their cash flow statements: of the pawn loan principal each company got back, the share that came from selling forfeited collateral rather than customer repayments. It was 40.7% at EZCORP for the fiscal year ended September 30, 2026, and 38.4% at FirstCash for the first nine months of 2026. It's weighted by dollars, not by number of loans, and it includes both companies' Latin American stores (and FirstCash's U.K. stores).

Do pawn loan rate caps apply to military members?

Yes. EZCORP's annual report notes that the federal Military Lending Act limits loans to covered active-duty service members and their dependents, including pawn loans, to a 36% military annual percentage rate. If you're covered and a pawn shop quotes you a monthly rate in the double digits, ask how the loan complies.

Is it better to pawn or sell gold jewelry?

If you're confident you can repay within the first term, a pawn loan lets you keep the piece. If you aren't, sell it. A forfeited item is gone and the fees you paid along the way are gone too. EZCORP's own numbers show it sold scrap jewelry at a 31.6% gross margin in its U.S. stores, so the shop expects to get meaningfully more for the gold than it paid or lent against it. Get quotes from at least two other buyers before you accept the first number.

Ready to compare?

Find your best Personal Loans match in 2 minutes.

Free to compare. No spam, no commitment.