Free to compare · No sign-up
How it worksAd disclosure
Article

Passed the FAFSA ID Check and Still Got Rejected? 13,000 Applicants Did. Check Your Submission Summary This Week.

Federal Student Aid says that from September 18 to October 4, 2026, about 13,000 applicants who passed the FAFSA identity check were wrongly rejected anyway. It reprocessed them on November 19, and another 15,000 who couldn't finish the check are getting a Student Aid Index this week. Here's what to look for.

A mother and her teenage daughter talking over breakfast at a kitchen table

If your family filed or corrected a FAFSA in late September and got told the application was rejected over identity, open it again this week. There’s a decent chance the government rejected you by mistake, and it’s fixing that now.

What went wrong

Since April, every FAFSA runs through a real-time fraud screen. Federal Student Aid says it built it “in partnership with a leading financial services firm.” Applicants rated High Risk have to prove who they are on the spot: a photo of a driver’s license or passport and a live camera check on a phone.

Here’s the part FSA admitted on November 17. From September 18 through October 4, 2026, applicants who passed that check were “mistakenly assigned Reject Code 74 and Comment Code 355, despite successfully verifying their identities.” About 13,000 of them. They did everything right and got the same reject as someone who walked away.

FSA reprocessed those applications on November 19. A second group, about 15,000 people who were picked for the check but couldn’t finish it (FSA’s example is a student not yet enrolled anywhere), is being reprocessed over the next week. Those still rated High Risk will finish verification with their school later. Either way, both groups can now get a Student Aid Index.

The notice went out on FSA’s site for financial aid offices. If you’re a parent, you probably didn’t see it.

Why a few weeks matters

A rejected FAFSA has no SAI, the number schools and states use to work out aid. No SAI, no aid offer. And in 11 states, grant money goes to whoever files first. A filing stuck in reject status since September can quietly lose its place in line.

Fraud is real. The Justice Department’s ghost student case shows why the screen exists. But a filter that rejects 13,000 people who passed it isn’t stopping fraud. It’s stalling legitimate students, and FSA’s fix only works if families notice it.

Do this now

  1. Log in at StudentAid.gov and open your FAFSA Submission Summary. You’re looking for an SAI. If one is there, you’re through.
  2. No SAI yet? Look for other reject codes. FSA says the SAI only appears once you’ve resolved any other rejects on the application. Fix those first.
  3. Still stuck on the identity reject after this week? Call a school’s financial aid office. Pick one on your FAFSA. Since May 3, schools can check your ID documents themselves and clear the reject in FSA’s system.
  4. Moved to V4 verification? Have your ID ready. Your school will ask you to prove your identity once you enroll. Answer fast, because aid waits on it.

FSA says it will rerun this cleanup monthly “until further notice.” Don’t count on that for your timing. Check this week, while there’s still time to make state deadlines.

Planning to borrow on top of aid? Our student loan calculator shows the monthly payment before you sign. More on paying for college is in the education hub.

How Candid Yak makes money. Some of the products we write about pay us if you apply or sign up through our links. That never changes our verdict, our rankings, or the numbers in this article. We call a bad deal a bad deal whether it pays us or not. Some brands shown in our comparison tools are placeholder examples while we finalize partner agreements, and we label them as such.

Frequently asked questions

What is FAFSA Reject Code 74?

It's the reject the FAFSA system adds when an applicant flagged as High Risk for identity fraud doesn't clear the online identity check. Federal Student Aid's fraud guidance says a High Risk applicant who fails the check gets Reject Code 74 with Comment Code 354, and one who doesn't complete it gets Reject Code 74 with Comment Code 355. A rejected FAFSA doesn't produce a Student Aid Index (SAI).

Who was wrongly rejected?

Federal Student Aid says that from September 18 through October 4, 2026, High Risk applicants who successfully completed identity verification were mistakenly given Reject Code 74 and Comment Code 355. About 13,000 applicants were affected. FSA fixed the problem for new applications on October 4 and scheduled the affected ones for reprocessing on November 19.

I couldn't finish the identity check. What happens to me?

FSA says about 15,000 applicants were selected for identity verification but didn't complete it and may not be able to soon, for example because they aren't enrolled at a school yet. It adjusted its fraud model. Applicants still rated High Risk move to V4 verification, which they finish with their school once enrolled. The rest don't need further identity verification. Both groups can get an SAI on the FAFSA Submission Summary if they fix any other reject codes. FSA is reprocessing these over the week after November 17 and says it will repeat this monthly.

What if my FAFSA still shows a reject after the reprocessing?

Check whether a different reject code is holding it up and fix that first. If the identity reject is still there, contact the financial aid office at a school on your FAFSA. Since May 3, 2026, schools have been able to confirm a student's identity with documents and clear the reject through an FAA Fraud Override field, which generates a new transaction.

Ready to compare?

Find your best Education match in 2 minutes.

Free to compare. No spam, no commitment.